SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Tompkins (5th Ed.), Chapter 1

Chapter 1 presents an overview of the cognitive, psycholinguistic, and sociolinguistic learning theories that provide the foundation for the approach to language arts instruction presented in the textbook.Components of this foundation are:

* Children learn through immersion in their environment.

* Children actively construct their knowledge through interaction with the environment.

* Adults facilitate children’s learning through modeling and providing scaffolds.

* Adults expect children to be successful.

1.What is your understanding of “HOW CHILDREN LEARN”?What do you remember about your own early learning experiences. What are the traditional beliefs about how children learn?

2. How does the way children learn to talk influence how they learn to read and write?

3. Based on how children learn language arts, how should language arts programs be developed for elementary schools?

4. What are some learning strategies that elementary children use to learn?

5. What is Piaget’s contribution to learning theory?

6. What did Vygotsky add to learning theory?

7.Explain the four Language Systems.

8. What are some guidelines for supporting and valuing students’ native language?

9.Discuss the characteristics of competent language users that are reflected in the Standards for the English Language Arts, 1996.

10. What does our author mean by a “Community of Learners”?

11.What are the characteristics of a Classroom Community?

Tompkins, Chapter 2

Chapter 2 is organized into three sections - language arts classrooms/materials and patterns of practice.Second, four instructional practices are discussed.Finally the chapter closes with assessing student learning

1. How and in what ways does the classroom environment reflect a teachers’ goals for theirstudents?

2.What materials are needed to facilitate students’ learning?

3. What is the teacher’s role in planning and implementing instructional programs?

4.Discuss the physical arrangement of a language rich classroom.Be sure to address earlychildhood, primary grades and upper grades.

5. Define trade books.What are the major types that you will want to include in your classroom?

6. Discuss way that technology can be integrated into the language arts classroom.

7. Be able to explain the four approaches for teaching the language arts.What characteristics will they have in common?

8. Discuss how the teacher’s job has evolved into a complex and multidimensional role.

9. How will you be able to adapt to meet the needs of every student?

10. Why is assessment such a difficult and complex part of the language arts?

11. What are some ways to monitor students’ progress in the language arts classroom?Be able to explain the different procedures.

12. Why is grading such a difficult task in the language arts classroom?How can authenticassessment procedures assist you?

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

Tompkins, Chapter 3, Reading and Writing Processes

This chapter presents reading and writing as parallel processes of meaning construction in which readers and writers use similar strategies for making meaning with text.The chapter is divided into three sections - the reading process, the writing process, and connections between reading and writing.

THE READING PROCESS

Aesthetic and Efferent Reading

Stage 1: Preparing to Read

Stage 2: Reading

Stage 3: Responding

Stage 4: Exploring the text

Stage 5: Extending the Interpretation

Teaching the Reading Processes

THE WRITING PROCESS

Stage 1: Prewriting

Stage 2: Drafting

Stage 3: Revising

Stage 4: Editing

Stage 5: Publishing

Teaching the Writing Process

CONNECTIONS BETWEEN READING AND WRITING

_____________________________________________________________________________

1.Discuss the similarities/differences you see between reading and writing.

2.List characteristics of the different stages of the reading process.

3.List characteristics of the different stages of the writing process.

4.Explain the “Goldilocks Strategy” and list the three categories of books in this strategy.

5.Describe how a teacher leads students through a class collaborations writing project.

6.Select one of the books provided and briefly develop a plan for a literature focus unit using thereading process.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

Tompkins, Chapter 4: Emerging Into Literacy

Chapter 4 explores the idea of how children become literate, taking the position that they emerge into reading and writing in much the same way as the learn to talk - by being immersed in language.

FOSTERING YOUNG CHILDREN’S INTEREST IN LITERACY

Concepts about Written Language

1.Concept of word

2.Environmental print

3.Dramatic play centers

Concepts about the Alphabet

1.The Alphabetic Principle

2.Letter Names

3.Phonemic Awareness

4.Phoneme-grapheme Correspondence

YOUNG CHILDREN EMERGE INTO READING

Adapting literature focus units for emergent readers

1.Shared Reading

2. Guided Reading

3.Language Experience Approach

YOUNG CHILDREN EMERGE INTO WRITING

Introducing young children to writing

Interactive Writing

Minilessons About Reading and Writing

Chapter 4 (cont)

1.What concepts about written language do young children need to understand as they learn to read and write?

2. How can teachers extend and support young children as they emerge into reading?

3. How can teachers extend and support young children as they emerge into writing?

4. How can parents and caregivers promote emergent literacy?

5. Describe “kid writing” and explain how it might help or hinder emerging wirters.

6. Name and describe the steps in shared reading.

7. Do you think the language experience approach is an effective way to help children

emerge into reading?Why or why not?

8. Brainstorm ideas about what you might want to include in a letter to parents that will explain how you will use “developmental spelling” as you students begin to write.What will be some common objections that parents might express?

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

Chapter 5: Looking Closely at Words

Tompkins

Chapter 5 focuses on vocabulary and how to help students learn and use words.

HISTORY OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE

WORDS AND THEIR MEANINGS

Root Words and Affixes

Synonyms and Antonyms

Homonyms

Multiple Meanings

Figurative Language

Borrowed Words

Other Sources of Words

TEACHING STUDENTS ABOUT WORDS

Word Walls

Word Study Activities

Teaching Minilessons

Adapting to Meet the Needs of Every Student

Assessing Students’ Knowledge of Words

Reflect on the ineffectiveness of traditional vocabulary activities such as looking up the definition of a list of words in a dictionary or using vocabulary words in sentences.Instead, how can students think about more innovative and meaningful ways to learn vocabulary.

1. How does a knowledge about the history of English help students understand the meanings ofwords?

2.How do root words (base words), prefixes, suffixes affect the meaning of words?

3.Discuss the amount of growth in an elementary student’s vocabulary each year.

4. How will you make vocabulary learning more interesting in your classroom?

5.Suggest several ways to assess vocabulary.

6. How do elementary students learn new words?

7. Explain how to do a word sort.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS - Chapter 6: 

Personal Writing, Tompkins

This chapter on personal writing is divided into two parts.The first part discusses the types of journals appropriate for the elementary classroom, and the second part of the chapter focuses on letter writing.

TYPES OF JOURNALS

Personal Journals

Dialogue Journals

Reading Logs

Double-Entry Journals

Language Arts Notebooks

Learning Logs

Simulated Journals

Young Children’s Journals

Teaching Students to Write in Journals

Assessing Students’ Journal Entries

LETTER WRITING

Friendly Letters

Business Letters

Teaching Students to Write Letters

Assessing Students’ Letters

1. What are some purposes of journal writing?

2.What kinds of journal writing activities are possible for elementary students?Varyingages?

3. How can journal writing help students learn?

4.How do teachers manage journal writing in the classroom?

5. How can teachers assess students’ journal entries?

6. Describe quickwriting and explain when it might be a useful strategy for students to use.

7.How can the Internet stimulate students’ letter writing?

8.How might you adapt journal writing activities to meet the needs of all your students?

9. Imagine you are a 5th grade teacher with students whose enthusiasm for journal writinghas waned.How might you rekindle their interest in journal writing?

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS - Chapter 7:

Listening to Learn, Tompkins

Listening is the first language mode that children develop and the most frequently used mode by both children and adults.Listening plays a significant role both in education and in life, and it is critical that teachers understand the process and know how to teach listening strategies.

THE LISTENING PROCESS

Purposes for Listening

Listening Strategies

AESTHETIC LISTENING

Strategies for Aesthetic Listening

Reading Aloud to Students

Multimedia Presentation Formats

Teaching Aesthetic Listening

Assessing Students’ Aesthetic Listening

EFFERENT LISTENING

Strategies for Efferent Listening

Teaching Efferent Listening

Assessing Students’ Efferent Listening

CRITICAL LISTENING

Persuasion and Propaganda

Strategies for Critical Listening

Teaching Critical Listening

Assessing Student’s Critical Listening



Chapter 7 (Continued)

1.Describe the steps in the listening process.

2.Why is listening instruction needed in the elementary grades?

3.What are the different types of listening?

4.How will you teach these different types of listening? 

5.How will you assess listening?

6.How might students make listening a more “visible” process?

7.Imagine you are a 7th grade teacher, and you are developing a unit on persuasive language.Use the six-step teaching strategy presented in Chapter 7 the explain how you might teachpropaganda devices using television commercials.

8.Imagine you are a first grade teacher, and you plan to share Beatrix Potter’s classic The Taleof Peter Rabbit with your students.You will read it aloud using the Directed Listening-Thinking Approach (DLTA).Explain the steps you will follow suing the before reading,during reading, and after reading strategy presented in Chapter 7.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS - Chapter 8:

Sustaining Talk in the Classroom, Tompkins

Chapter 8 emphasizes the fact that talk is an essential part of the language arts curriculum and is necessary for learning in all content areas.Research shows that talk is a necessary ingredient for learning and complements students’ written language development.

AESTHETIC TALK

Conversations about Literature

Adapting to Meet the Needs of Every Student

Storytelling

Readers Theatre

EFFERENT TALK

Instructional Conversations

Show-and-Tell

Oral Reports

Interviews

Debates

DRAMATIC ACTIVITIES

Role-Playing

Puppets and Other Props

Script writing and Theatrical Productions

1. Why is talk important in an elementary classroom?

2. In what types of aesthetic talk activities do elementary students participate?

3. In what types of efferent talk activities do elementary students participate?

4. How can talk activities be integrated into literature focus units and theme cycles?

5. Describe the steps in the interview process.

6. Discuss the strengths of a grand conversation

7. How can you make show-and-tell more beneficial to your students?

CHAPTER 9: READING AND WRITING STORIES

DEVELOPING STUDENTS’ CONCEPT OF STORY

Elements of story structure

Plot

Characters

Setting

Point of view

Theme

Teaching Students about stories

Adapting to meet the needs of students

Assessing students’ knowledge of stories

READING STORIES

Comprehension

Assessing Students’ Comprehension of Stories

WRITING STORIES

Writing Retellings of Stories

Writing Innovations on Texts

Writing Sequels

Writing Genre Stories

Assessing the Stories Students Write

1.How can teachers help students become lifelong readers?

2.How do students learn the elements of story structure?

3. How can teachers assist students in reading and writing stories?

4.What are some conflict situations and astory that illustrates each?

5.What are some activities that encourage students to further explore stories they have read?

6.Suggest some writing activities that students might engage in as projects during the extending stage of the reading process

7.How will you assess students’ stories?

8. How will you involve your students in genuine and meaningful reading/writing experiences?

CHAPTER 10: Reading and Writing Information

DEVELOPING STUDENTS’ KNOWLEDGE ABOUT INFORMATIONAL BOOKS

Types of informational books

Expository text structures

Teaching students about expository text structures

Assessing students’ use of expository text structures

REPORTS OF INFORMATION

Visual Reports

“All About...” Reports

Collaborative and Individual Reports

Multigenre Reports

Teaching Students to Write Reports

Assessing students’ research report

LIFE-STORIES

Reading Biographies and Autobiographies

Teaching Students to Write Autobiographies

Teaching Students to Write Biographies

Adapting to Meet the Needs of Every Student

Assessing Students’ Life Stories

1.What is the difference between stories and informational books?

2. How can teachers help students connect the reading and writing of information?

3.What are the advantages/disadvantages of collaborative versus individual reports?

4. How can students make use of lifelines in writing biographies/autobiographies?

5.Explain some strategies you will use to teach letter writing.

6. How might you incorporate theme cycles with reading and writing biographies?

7.Explain how you might include four types of informational writing in connection with a social studies theme cycle.

8. How do elementary students write research reports?

9. Discuss the formats for visual reports

CHAPTER 11:READING AND WRITING POETRY

PLAYING WITH WORDS

Laughing with language

Creating word pictures

Experimenting with rhyme

Other poetic devices (Comparison, alliteration, onomatopoeia, repetition)

READING POEMS

Types of poems children read

Children’s favorite poems

Assessing students’ experiences with poems

WRITING POEMS

Formula poems

Free-form poems

Syllable- and word-count poems

Rhymed verse forms

Model poems

Teaching students to write poems

Adapting to meet the needs of every student

Assessing poems students write

1. What are some things teachers can do to encourage students’ interest in poetry during theelementary grades?

2.Explain five poetic devices?

3.Why is it important that teachers help students develop a concept of poetry before writingpoems?

4.Why are class collaborations crucial when introducing new poetic forms for students to try?

5.Imagine you a re a fifth grade teacher, and you discover that your students have never written poetry before and they have many misconceptions about poetry.What will you do?

6.Imagine you are a kindergarten teacher, and you would like to involve your students in poetry writing activities.Explain how you would teach your students to write poetry and three types of poems your students can “write.”

CHAPTER 12: Learning to Spell Conventionally

Spelling is a tool for writers that allows them to communicate conventionally with readers.This chapter begins with a discussion of spelling development, including the sometimes controversial invented spelling.Then an explanation is given of how to analyze the child’s spelling errors in order to gain information about the writer’s level of spelling development.Finally strategies are given for teaching and assessing spelling.

Children’s Spelling Development

What is Invented Spelling?

Stages of Spelling Development

Analyzing Children’s Spelling Development

Teaching Spelling in Elementary Grades

Components of Spelling Instruction

Teaching Minilessons

Weekly Spelling Tests

Adapting to Meet the Needs of Every Student

Assessing Students’ Progress in Spelling

1. Discuss how you learned to spell.

2.How will you deal with parents who are apprehensive about invented spelling?

3.What is the role of invented spelling?

4. Discuss the stages and characteristics of invented spelling.

5. What are the six components of a comprehensive spelling instruction suggested in the chapter?

6. Describe the word sort strategy.

7. Explain how to design effective weekly spelling tests.

CHAPTER 13:Learning About Grammar and Usage

This chapter examines grammar, taking the position that instruction should be tied to writing, with the primary goal being communication.It begins with a presentation of grammatical concepts, such as parts of speech, parts of sentences, types of sentences, capitalization and punctuation, and usage.The second of the chapter is a discussion of why we should teach grammar, followed by strategies for teaching grammar in the elementary grades.

GRAMMATICAL CONCEPTS

Parts of Speech

Parts of Sentences

Types of Sentences

Capitalization and Punctuation

Usage

TEACHING GRAMMAR IN THE ELEMENTARY GRADES

Why Teach Grammar?

Teaching Grammar Through Reading

Teaching Grammar Through Writing

Teaching the Parts of Speech

Teaching Students to Manipulate Sentences

Teaching Minilessons

Adapting to Meet the Needs of Every Student

Assessing Students’ Knowledge About Grammar

1.Why should we teach grammar?

2. How can teacher tie grammar instruction to literature and writing?

3. Why is there such a controversy about teaching grammar?

4. What is the purpose of grammar instruction in the elementary grades?

5. Explain the process and purpose of sentence collecting.

6. Explain the process of Dunning’s copy changes.

7. Why is it important to tie grammar instruction to the editing stage of the writing process?

8. Discuss Killgallon’s four types of sentence manipulation.



CHAPTER 14: Developing Legible Handwriting

Tompkins

This chapter focuses on handwriting.The goal is presented as the development of legible and fluent handwriting.First, the forms are discussed: manuscript, and cursive.D-Nealian is an additional style of writing.Next, handwriting development is presented.The special needs of left-handed writers are also presented.Keyboarding is also mentioned as an important skill to facilitate technological communication.

HANDWRITING FORMS

CHILDREN’S HANDWRITING DEVELOPMENT

Handwriting Before First Grade

Handwriting in the Primary Grades

Transition to Cursive Handwriting

Handwriting in the Middle and Upper Grades

TEACHING HANDWRITING IN THE ELEMENTARY GRADES

Elements of Legibility

Teaching Minilessons

Working with Left-Handed Writers

Diagnosing and Correcting Handwriting Problems

Keyboarding: An Alternative to Handwriting

Adapting to Meet the needs of Every Student

1. What are the roles of public and private handwriting?

2. How can teachers help left-handed writers?

3. How can teachers assess handwriting?

4. Describe the elements of legible handwriting.

5. Describe the sequence of children’s handwriting development.

6. Describe ways in which children’s handwriting instruction can be individualized.

CHAPTER 15: PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER

This culminating chapter emphasizes the application of what has been covered throughout the book.

LITERATURE FOCUS UNITS

LITERATURE CIRCLES

READING AND WRITING WORKSHOP

THEME CYCLES

1.How do teachers bring all the language arts together to create meaningful learning activities within a workshop environment?

2.What are some important reasons for using multicultural literature in elementary classroom even when students in that classroom do not represent diverse cultures?

3.What is a workshop environment and how will you establish it in your classroom?

4. List some approaches for incorporating multicultural literature into literature focus units and them cycles.

5. Describe how you would go about monitoring student work in a workshop environment.

6.List the stereotypes you would avoid when sharing literature about diverse cultures.